In Episode 2 of Batman: The Enemy Within, Bruce Wayne found himself behind enemy lines working as a member of The Pact, a coalition of villains hatching a plan to wreak havoc in Gotham City. In Episode 3, Fractured Mask, developer Telltale pumps the brakes on high-stakes schemes in favour of something a little more intimate. The result is an episode that only inches the overarching narrative forward, but takes a big leap in exploring the fragile nature of Bruce Wayne’s duality.
At the end of the last episode, Catwoman who has been absent since Season 1 made a surprise return, and in Episode 3 it’s revealed she’s in league with Harley, Bane, Mr. Freeze, and John “Not The Joker Yet” Doe. But Catwoman is also driven to take revenge against The Pact and the mysterious forces they represent for the death of Riddler. Through her, Fractured Mask re-contextualizes Riddler’s actions somewhat by indicating that his plans may not have aligned completely with his villainous compatriots. The Riddler that Catwoman knew was a different, better person than the one Batman faced, and ultimately the one The Pact killed. With this in mind, she takes it into her own hands to seek retribution.
Naturally, this places Bruce in a tricky spot. Since Catwoman’s plans threaten to undermine his own efforts as an undercover operative for Amanda Waller, the two find themselves at odds professionally. Complicating matters even further is the burgeoning romance between them which, amongst the deception and subterfuge, allows them to find some comfort in each other and not completely descend into darkness. This dynamic is at the core of Episode 3 and, for the most part, it is depicted well. Although there are a couple of scenes where Catwoman’s attitude pivots jarringly, these eventually culminate in a moment of genuine emotional payoff where the player can choose to develop their relationship in a meaningful way.
Bruce Wayne and Batman’s other ties become equally messy in Episode 3. Most impactfully, his friendship with Jim Gordon takes a serious turn for the worse. Since Batman is playing nice with Amanda Waller, who is wrestling control of Gotham’s law enforcement operations away from Gordon, the two begin to drift apart. Episode 3 presents a Gordon who has his back against the wall and is desperately trying to remain relevant. He clutches at straws hoping to grasp something significant and, unfortunately, this results in Bruce finding himself in Gordon’s cross-hairs. It’s actually quite sad to see Batman’s staunchest ally slowly becoming his demise. Although there is an opportunity to begin repairing this fracturing friendship, taking this step will damage another important one. There aren’t very many big decision-making moments in Episode 3, but the few that are there carry enough consequence to make the player pause and think.
Episode 3 also sees old wounds reopened, with Lucius Fox’s daughter, Tiffany, becoming embroiled in Batman and Bruce Wayne’s activities. As a character, Tiffany hasn’t had much screen time but the events of the episode raise her profile considerably. Without spoiling the story, Telltale seems to be motioning towards something that, if it happens, could be very exciting for fans of Batman and for this series.
And then, throughout it all is John Doe, the man being positioned to become Joker. He’s a lingering presence that is both charming and unsettling, and Episode 3 hops back and forth between those two personas expertly. Doe continues to be a fascinating take on the character; unsure of who he is but very slowly dipping into the madness that will inevitably consume him. His need to find acceptance sees him craving Harley Quinn’s attention, to the point where he puts both himself and his “best friend” Bruce in danger. As with the previous two episodes, John Doe is a standout character, providing levity with some excellently delivered one-liners, throwaway quips, and one hilarious sequence involving shadow puppets.
While Episode 3 has strong characterization, its gameplay feels rather shallow. Outside of the fight sequences, which are well choreographed but a little trite, there’s one big puzzle for players to solve. It takes place in Riddler’s hideout and, given his love of flaunting his intelligence, you’d think it would be elaborate and challenging. However, it’s actually trivial to solve, making Riddler seem a bit dull talk about kicking someone when he’s already down.
Nevertheless, Episode 3 of Telltale’s Batman: The Enemy Within is well thought out and strongly written. Telltale has weaved together a complicated web of relationships that’s becoming strained by the people tangled in it. After two relatively straightforward episodes, this is exactly what the series needed to carry it forward and ensure players are compelled to see it through.